{
  "proof_id": "first-independent-canonical-replay",
  "headline": "H33 was removed from the process and the organization still replayed identically.",
  "binary": "h33-independent-canonical-replay",
  "label": "Evidence Case · claim-84711",
  "inputs": {
    "events_file": "cases/claim-84711/events.json",
    "manifest_file": "cases/claim-84711/manifest.json",
    "tenant_id": "tenant_insurance_claim_44962d9b-25f5-5622-bd9a-98d5580bb8a2",
    "tenant_root": "princ_root_claim_44962d9b-25f5-5622-bd9a-98d5580bb8a2",
    "target_t_ms": 2064614400000,
    "event_count": 12
  },
  "structural_checks": {
    "every_event_parsed": true,
    "every_event_has_signature": true,
    "expected_verdict": "Valid",
    "actual_verdict": "Valid",
    "verdict_matches": true
  },
  "replay": {
    "computed_state_id": "e72d3c0e71a11ce0aaf1e8c9eb5c720aff49a6238c76976b4f4435b50e43bee2",
    "active_grants": 2,
    "active_policy_versions": 2,
    "active_model_versions": 1,
    "decisions_present": 2,
    "excluded_authorities": 0
  },
  "state_id_comparison": {
    "expected": "e72d3c0e71a11ce0aaf1e8c9eb5c720aff49a6238c76976b4f4435b50e43bee2",
    "computed": "e72d3c0e71a11ce0aaf1e8c9eb5c720aff49a6238c76976b4f4435b50e43bee2",
    "matches": true
  },
  "confidence": {
    "score": 76,
    "checks": [
      {
        "name": "authority_chain",
        "passed": true,
        "severity": "Critical",
        "note": "All grants traced to root."
      },
      {
        "name": "signatures_verified_at_replay",
        "passed": false,
        "severity": "Critical",
        "note": "Phase E lock: AuthEvent.signature is stored but not verified at replay ingestion. Standalone L9 verifier will close this."
      },
      {
        "name": "policy_versions_present",
        "passed": true,
        "severity": "Warning",
        "note": "Every decision's policy_version_ref resolves to a registered policy version (or no decisions emitted)."
      },
      {
        "name": "model_versions_present",
        "passed": true,
        "severity": "Warning",
        "note": "Every decision's model_version_ref resolves to a registered model version (or no decisions emitted)."
      },
      {
        "name": "decision_lineage_resolves",
        "passed": true,
        "severity": "Info",
        "note": "Every decision's parent_decision_ids resolve to earlier decisions in the snapshot."
      },
      {
        "name": "decisions_during_active_authority",
        "passed": true,
        "severity": "Warning",
        "note": "Every decision was made while the actor's authority was in a valid lifecycle state."
      }
    ]
  },
  "determination": "PASS — H33 was removed from the process and the organization replayed identically.",
  "overall_pass": true,
  "honest_scope": "L9.1 — verifies structural replay determinism AND, when --verify-signatures is set, per-event PQ signatures (ML-DSA-65 + FALCON-512 + SLH-DSA-SHA2-128f). Verified ≠ True. Signer identity (Phase F) remains out of scope."
}